I had an 8-pound Fiskars X27, a cottonwood chopping block, and roughly zero idea what I was getting into.
This was the fall of 2017. First real winter in the 1,800 sq ft cape in upstate New York, new wood stove in the living room, and a guy down the road who’d sell me log-length truckloads for cheap if I bucked and split them myself. I added it up on a napkin. Five cords for the season. Figured I’d do a cord a weekend from September through the end of October and be stacked and smug by Halloween.
Reader… I was not stacked and smug by Halloween.
The maul does not care about your plans
The first Saturday went great. Dry ash, 16-inch rounds, straight grain. The X27 is a weirdly good tool — it looks like a composite toy next to my grandfather’s old true-temper maul, but the head geometry pops straight-grained rounds like they’re trying to open themselves. I banged out most of a cord before lunch and thought, well, this is going to be easy.
Then the oak showed up.
Northern red oak rounds, 14 to 18 inches across, cut green the week before. A green red oak round laughs at you. You hit it dead-center, dead-straight, with 8 pounds of steel moving fast, and the maul just… stops. Buried an inch deep. No crack. No pop. You wiggle it out and do it again. On a bad one I was putting six, eight, ten swings into a single round before it finally came apart in two half-moons.
Then the elm showed up, and that’s where I lost my religion. There’s a reason American elm has the reputation it does. The grain twists around itself like rope. I had a 20-inch round that I’m pretty sure is still out behind the shed, uncracked, waiting for the heat death of the universe. You could drive wedges into it all afternoon and it would just swallow them.
Every mistake, more or less in order
Here’s the dumb stuff I did that first fall, and the carry-over into the next winter, in roughly the order I did it.
- Split on bare dirt. I didn’t have a proper block for the first two weekends, so I was popping rounds right on the ground. Second Saturday I drove the X27 clean through a round, down into the dirt, and hit a rock the size of a fist. Put a nice warp in the handle right at the head. The maul still works — it’s a composite handle, basically indestructible — but it’s never swung quite true since.
- Swung with my arms. I grew up watching my uncle split with his shoulders and arms, like he was swinging a sledge at a railroad spike. Turns out he’s got a bad back now. The right way is almost entirely legs and hips — you’re basically doing a controlled fall and the maul is just along for the ride. I did not know this. I learned it, slowly, through pain.
- Didn’t noodle the ugly ones. A chainsaw with a ripping cut down the middle of a knotty round turns an un-splittable rock into two easy pieces. I owned a chainsaw. I had bar oil. I just refused to use it, because in my head splitting meant splitting, not sawing. Pure stubbornness. Cost me probably ten hours over two winters.
- Tried to split frozen rounds. January 2018, 12 degrees out, and I decided I was going to get ahead on next year’s wood. Frozen rounds do split easier in some species, which is true, but they also shatter. Cracked one open and a knot the size of a softball spit out sideways and smacked the dog, who was supervising from what she thought was a safe distance. She was fine. She did not supervise me again that winter.
- Pushed through the warning signs. The right shoulder started barking around New Year’s. I ignored it. By mid-February I woke up one morning and could not lift my arm over my head to put on a shirt. Had to roll onto my side and shimmy into it like a seal. The urgent care doc said tendinitis, maybe the start of a frozen shoulder, told me to stop swinging anything heavy for six weeks, and handed me a script for an anti-inflammatory. My wife, who is a saint, did not say “I told you so.” She did not have to.
When hand-splitting actually makes sense
- You're doing a cord or less a season, not four or five.
- The wood is straight-grained — ash, soft maple, cherry, pine, birch.
- The rounds are 16 inches or shorter and under about 14 inches across.
- You've got a real chopping block, not bare dirt, not concrete.
- Your back and shoulders are in good enough shape that a Saturday of swinging won't end you.
- You enjoy it. If splitting by hand is your meditation, keep going. If it's a chore, rent or buy a splitter.
If more than one or two of those don’t apply to you, you’re the guy I was in 2017. Learn from the shoulder.
The $380 cord that ended the experiment
February 2018, I had maybe a cord and a half of oak still sitting in rounds, a shoulder that didn’t work, and a stove that burned through split wood faster than I could keep up with even if I’d been healthy. Bought a cord of split, half-dry oak off a guy up the road for $380. That was the first time I’d ever paid retail for wood, and it stung. It wasn’t even good wood — and that very next fall I’d get properly burned on the same move in the smoke year. Different seller, same lesson about the word “seasoned.”
I limped through the rest of that winter, split the easier ash and maple one-handed on the good days, and put the maul in the back of the shed in March with a bad attitude about it.
April 2019: the splitter
A guy two towns over was selling a towable 25-ton splitter with a Honda GX160 on it. $900. I drove out in the Ranger with cash in an envelope and a weirdly reverent feeling. Got it home that Saturday, fueled it up, and split every oak round still sitting from the previous fall in one afternoon. Elm included. The elm that had defeated me all winter popped apart in about four seconds under 25 tons of hydraulic pressure. I think I laughed out loud.
Five cords in two afternoons, instead of six weeks of weekends. Seven and a half years later it’s the same splitter, same engine, same pump. Oil change every spring, stabilizer in the gas every fall, and it fires on the second pull pretty much every time. Good Honda engine in it. Best $900 I’ve ever spent. Go Honda!!!
Is the maul useless now? No.
The X27 still lives on a nail inside the shed, and I still reach for it a couple times a week. If I only need to split four or five pieces to top off the rack by the back door, I’m not firing up the splitter for that. A warm Saturday in October with a pile of straight-grained ash and a cold beer is genuinely a nice way to spend an afternoon — which species make for a good afternoon and which make for a bad one is pretty much the whole point of the best firewood rankings. Splitting difficulty is right there in the data.
The other thing: splitting speeds up seasoning. A round takes forever to dry; a split piece dries in a season. I go into that in the seasoning guide, but the short version is: whatever you split today is what you’ll be burning next winter. So even on splitter days, a little maul work at the stack isn’t wasted.
What I’d tell 2017 me
If you’re young, fit, burning a cord or less, mostly straight-grained stuff, and you actually like the work: swing away. Use your legs, not your arms. Get a real block. Noodle the ugly rounds. Stop before your shoulder tells you to.
If you’re forty-something, running a stove full-time through a northeast winter, dealing with oak and elm and whatever the log guy dumps in your driveway, five cords deep — just buy the splitter. Used Honda-powered 25-ton units show up on Facebook Marketplace every spring for under a grand. You will not regret it. Your rotator cuff will not regret it.
My wife still calls that winter “the shoulder year.” The smoke year came right behind it, so now she says she’s going to start naming them like hurricanes. I don’t argue anymore.
Related reads
- The Year I Burned Green Oak — the next winter’s mistake
- Best Firewood Rankings — splitting difficulty, by species
- Firewood Seasoning Guide — why split wood dries so much faster